S&W 642 with its big brother, the .44 magnum 629
S&W 642 and 629

Concealment Gun: Smith & Wesson 642 with Crimson Trace (laser sight) grips.  If you only buy one gun for defense, this simple and easily-concealed revolver is it.  The laser sight compensates for the tiny sight radius, enhances dry-fire practice (which is important with a rough double-action only revolver trigger), enhances the deterrent value of the gun, makes it equally useful in all light conditions, and allows you to focus on a threat instead of on the front sight (as is necessary to make good hits with a conventional notch-and-post sight).

Since I bought and tested one in 2018, a Remington R51 (also with a laser sight) has taken the place of the S&W 642 as my preferred carry gun, simply because it’s a little less bulgy in a pocket holster.

Tactical Handgun: You can carry a lot more firepower with a magazine-fed gun, but you also need more training and practice to reliably use its more complicated action, which is prone to both operator-induced and mechanical malfunctions.

Fit is the first criterion for a handgun.  If it fits your hands get a Glock.  Otherwise find a quality gun that does fit you well and that shoots either 9mm or .357 SIG. (380 ACP is considered barely adequate for self-defense. Larger calibers are more expensive and difficult to shoot but do not appear to offer significant defensive benefits.)

Striker-fired Glock 17 (top) and DA/SA Sig P239
Glock 17 and Sig P239

Although I prefer striker-fired semi-autos I have also been impressed with high-quality double-action/single-action handguns like those by Sig-Sauer. A double-action on a semi-automatic may be seen as an unnecessary complication because the first trigger pull is longer and harder than follow-ups, and because it needs to be de-cocked after firing. But there are tactical benefits to the fast, light follow-up trigger pulls, and you may prefer that feature.

I am opposed in principle to handguns with manual safeties because those are unnecessarily complicated.  This rules out the popular 1911 design, but given the wide range of more modern drop-safe designs that omit manual safeties I think it’s a good rule.  (And no, manual safeties do not make handguns safer.  Any handgun should be expected to discharge when its trigger is pulled.  Holsters, gun safes, and obedience to the rules of safe gun handling keep a gun’s trigger from being pulled unintentionally.)

Final point: If you aren’t equipping the gun with a laser sight then spend the extra $100 for tritium-illuminated “night sights.”  Handguns are virtually useless in the dark when you can’t see the sights well enough to align them.

Of course, the only reason to carry a handgun is to fight your way to a long gun, so we continue:

Tactical Shotgun: Mossberg M590-A1For home defense get a pump-action shotgun, ideally a 12-gauge (because bigger is better when it comes to stopping an imminent threat!).  You can’t go wrong with a Mossberg 500-series or Remington 8xx.  Load it with buckshot.

Tactical Rifle: Ruger SR-556Ruger SR-556. I recommend the AR-15 platform because it is the standard American militia rifle — not only does everyone know how to operate and maintain it, but it also enjoys a vibrant and competitive market for parts and upgrades. However, since I abhor the dirty direct-gas impingement action of standard AR-15s I recommend the SR-556 for its elegant piston-driven action. Actually, I’ve come around on the piston-vs-DI question. Today I’d probably buy a POF Renegade Plus.

Precision Rifle: Savage 10FP (available in both .223 and .308).  In spite of its stand-offish customer service (which still doesn’t use Email!), Savage has made the most consistently accurate factory rifles at reasonable prices for many years.  This is thanks to a number of innovations (which are slowly trickling out to other manufacturers) that obviate the need for expensive custom finishing to achieve peak accuracy, including:

  • A barrel nut, making it simple for the factory to achieve perfect head-spacing.
  • The AccuTrigger, a crisp factory trigger that the user can easily adjust down to just 1.5-pounds.
  • A floating bolt head, which provides the same effect as hand-lapped fixed bolt lugs

Savage 10FP w Choate Ultimate Varmint StockThe 10FP series is ostensibly designed for police snipers, so it is available in some very nice tactical packages.  There is also a good range of third-party stocks available for it.  I am partial to the relatively inexpensive Choate Ultimate Varmint Stock shown here.

RFB and AUGPersonal Defense Weapon: Since a handgun is a stopgap weapon, but standard rifles and shotguns are unwieldy, you might want to carry a compact magazine-fed firearm that shoots a rifle round.  One of my favorite designs is the Steyr AUG, a bullpup carbine with a 16″ barrel that measures only 28″ overall. MSAR’s STG-556 is a clone with a number of improvements — most notably in terms of price. Kel-Tec’s RFB equally-compact bullpup steps up to the more powerful .308 cartridge.

AR-15, AUG, and XCR SBR length comparisonShown here for length comparison, top to bottom, is an AR-15 (the Ruger SR-556) with its stock fully collapsed, an AUG (the MSAR STG-556), and an XCR-L with an 11″ barrel and folded stock.

SCAR-style tactical rifles are also good candidates for this role: Unlike AR-15s they allow for folding stocks by putting the return spring over the piston rod. The Robinson Armament XCR is my recommended buy in this category.

AR-15 PistolFor even greater concealability pistols can be employed with slings and extended magazines to bridge the gap. An AR-15 pistol in .300BLK is a good crossover PDW.

Bullpups: I am a fan of bullpup rifle designs, which put the bolt and magazine in the stock behind the trigger guard, resulting in more compact and balanced guns. Reviews in this genre include:

7 thoughts on “Firearms

  1. Less Than Favorable

    Would you suggest the SIG Sauer P239 as a concealment gun as opposed to the S&W 642? Of course the SIG is much more expensive and complicated than the simple revolver, which may be a problem for some.

  2. federalist Post author

    If there’s any question go with the revolver. Even if money is no object it’s still more reliable and somewhat easier to carry. I have both, and I consider myself proficient with the P239, but for routine carry I’m always packing my 642.

    (The P239 doesn’t offer any advantage for the overwhelming majority of defensive scenarios in which concealed guns are employed. It is a finer gun, and yes, with practice you can fire more rounds more accurately and quickly than with the 642. But if you’re attracted to the extra capacity afforded by autoloaders you should also weigh the alternatives of carrying larger double-stack magazine guns against extra mags for the single-stack subcompact.)

  3. Fritz

    642 is an outstanding CCW pistol. Too bad Smith dropped the 9mm j-frame from their lineup. Taurus does one, but is prefer the Smith. For a bit more firepower, I opt for a Glock 19. The new Glock 43 looks like an outstanding CCW handgun as well.

  4. Less Than Favorable

    Lately you’ve been less active(which is completely understandable),but will you be able to get your hands on many firearms in 2016? Some new bullpups have been popping up and I’d like to see one, such as the RDB or newly re-envisioned K&M M17s, go against your AUG. Not to mention the Strike One you mentioned you had interest in is starting to get some reviews and I’d like to see what observations you have about it.

  5. federalist Post author

    Yes, we seem to be entering an age of plenty for bullpups! Which is depressing in a way because I don’t think I’ll be able to keep up. I will get to review a Tavor soon, so I haven’t completely given up 😉

    The last year or two I’ve been distracted with a few deeper research projects. I should probably write some of that stuff up for public benefit, but some is covered by NDA.

    But you’re right: There is enough radically new stuff out that it’s time to get back in the market!

  6. Less Than Favorable

    Bullpups and striker-fired handguns seem to be all the rage now, which is a dream come true! I’m not sure if anyone has kept up with all the newest guns, even the most popular firearm bloggers and reviewers haven’t covered them all to my knowledge.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *